| 22/8/2008 |
Bil-Malti
HOME
SERVICES
HELP
SEARCH
|
| Court of Appeal - Decisions in Income Tax Cases |
| Case No: 1 |
Decided on 30 April 1951 |
   |
|
Fresh Arguments (Or Reasons) Brought Forward On Appeal, As Against Fresh Grounds Of Objection.
|
The Income Tax Acts provide that a taxpayer who has received an assessment may file an objection thereagainst. This is the first stage of an appeal process granted to taxpayers. If disagreement still exists, the Commissioner of Inland Revenue serves a notice of refusal of the objection (in full or in part) on the taxpayer, who may then file an appeal thereagainst to the Board of Special Commissioners. A further appeal on points of law only thereafter lies to the Court of Appeal.
In filing a notice of objection, the taxpayer must state the precise grounds of his objection against the assessment. If the Commissioner disagrees with the grounds of objection filed by the taxpayer, he issues a notice of refusal rejecting the said grounds, in full or in part. Subsequent appeals to the Board and to the Court can, under normal legal processes, only be made in respect of these grounds.
In the present case, the taxpayer, while not changing the fundamental grounds of objection, changed his arguments against the assessment before the Board. The Revenue was of the opinion that, in this way, fresh new grounds of objection were being filed against the assessment. The Board of Special Commissioners rejected this approach, saying that fresh arguments or reasons brought forward at any stage of the appeal proceedings did not change the grounds on which the assessment was being contested.
The Court of Appeal agreed with the Board. Once the real merit of the appeal remains the same, there was no impediment to the use of fresh arguments. These should not be confused with grounds of objection. The legislation in no way limited the argumentation which could be used on appeal. Modern legal procedures abhorred restrictive formalities and were all in favour of allowing judges to be freely convinced.
BSC Case No: 8/50
|
|
|
|
|